Why it’s so hard to talk about e-cigarette risks

A growing proportion of American adults consider vapes just as or even more dangerous than cigarettes, according to a study out today. The findings illustrate just how hard it is to accurately convey the risks of e-cigarettes, especially when public health researchers are still working out what some of those risks actually are.

Part of the challenge is that the risk-benefit calculation for e-cigarettes depends on who’s using them. For adult smokers, completely switching to e-cigarettes may actually be less dangerous than smoking combustible cigarettes. But that doesn’t mean they’re completely safe: vapes haven’t been around long enough for us to know what their long-term harms might be, and at the moment, there’s little regulatory oversight of their ingredients, or their batteries — which sometimes, but rarely, explode. As for non-smoking adults and minors under the age of 18, they certainly shouldn’t be vaping because of the potential risks for heart and lung problems, as well as nicotine addiction that might eventually lead to cigarette smoking.

It’s a complicated public health message to digest — and today’s study, published in the journal JAMA Network Open, suggests that some of it is getting lost in translation. It’s understandable that the public doesn’t know what to think, because the science is still evolving, according to Gideon St. Helen, a tobacco researcher at the University of California, San Francisco, who was not involved in the study. “It’s not like the tobacco control community is united in terms of their opinion of electronic cigarettes,” he says. “Some people believe electronic cigarettes are bad, and some people believe they’re like the second coming of Christ.”

Jidong Huang, an associate professor of health management and policy at Georgia State University, wanted to know what that means for the public’s perception of vapes. “We don’t know what Americans now think about e-cigarettes,” he says. “Do they believe e-cigarettes are safe, or do they believe that e-cigarettes are more harmful?” So for this study, he and a team of researchers analyzed the results from two different surveys: one was an online survey conducted by Georgia State University, and the other was conducted by the National Cancer Institute. Starting in 2012, both surveys asked thousands of adults how risky they thought e-cigarettes were compared to regular cigarettes.

The team found that by 2017, more adults developed feelings about e-cigarettes. And in both surveys, the proportion of people who thought e-cigarettes were less harmful than regular cigarettes dropped between 2012 and 2017, with the biggest drop between 2012 and 2015. At the same time, the percentage of people who thought e-cigarettes were just as bad as cigarettes climbed. And while few adults thought e-cigarettes were more harmful than cigarettes in 2017 — 4.3 percent in one study and 9.9 percent in the other — that’s still a big increase from the 1.3 percent and 2.8 percent who thought that in 2012.

What those results mean, according to Huang, is that people have an imperfect understanding of the risks of e-cigarettes — especially compared to cigarettes (which, according to the CDC, “are extraordinarily dangerous, killing half of all people who smoke long-term.”) “What we were trying to say is actually it is very difficult to accurately communicate to the public,” he says.

Robert Jackler, a professor of otorhinolaryngology at Stanford, thinks that some of the confusion is because the public is becoming better, but unevenly, informed about e-cigarettes through the media. The dangerous risks of cigarettes are old news. But the health risks of e-cigarettes are newsworthy — so when scientists discover chemicals in them that can cause lung irritation or heart problems, or when vapes explode and vape juice poisons children, we report it.

“Most of us would like to see adult smokers leave their combustibles behind and move to vapor,” he says. Raising concerns about e-cigarettes is appropriate, he says, but can also lead to confusion about their relative risks compared to cigarettes. “All you see as a reader of news online is one report after another revealing the newsworthy fact that vaping is not perfectly safe. And people misunderstand the concept of safety versus safer.” He compares cigarettes to speeding down the highway at 90 miles per hour, and e-cigarettes to a more reasonable — but still fast — 75 miles per hour. “Both increase your risk of death, but speeding at 75 is nowhere near as risky of death or injury as speeding at 90.”

Getting the messaging wrong could be risky for public health, Huang says. On the one hand, overblowing the risks of e-cigarettes demonizes what may be a potentially less dangerous (albeit still risky) alternative to cigarettes for adult smokers; on the other hand, underselling the risks could wind up increasing teen vaping, he says. That means it’s key to tailor messaging to specific groups, in specific channels, Huang says. So campaigns on social media, which may reach a young audience, shouldn’t focus on the fact that e-cigarettes may be less risky than the regular kind. But that message might be appropriate for AARP magazine, which is more likely to reach adult smokers.

The study authors point out a big limitation with their own study: the data stop at 2017, which is before the massive spike in teen e-cigarette use that prompted the US Surgeon General to call teen vaping an “epidemic.” It’s also before big tobacco company Altria paid $12.8 billion to buy a chunk of e-cigarette giant Juul. So it’s possible that risk perception has changed since then. Another problem is that one of the surveys waffled on what to call vapes — switching from e-cigarettes early on to electronic vapor products in the latter years of the survey. That could make it hard to compare from year to year. And Michael Ong, a professor of medicine and public health at UCLA, says the surveys didn’t get into how people perceive different kinds of risks — like heart problems, cancer, or exploding devices.

Still, the results from both surveys back each other up. And for public health experts like St. Helen, the findings mean we need to get better at communicating risk — although striking the right balance is tricky. “I don’t think it’s okay to scare people into believing that something is risky that is potentially not as risky as you say. Because then it makes people question the scientific community,” he says. “The public can see through that anyway.”

L317 电子烟的更多相关文章

  1. Python第七章(北理国家精品课 嵩天等)

    7.1文件的使用 1.1文本类型 文本文件:由单一特定编码组成的文件,如.txt 二进制文件:如.png,.avi 1.2文件的打开和关闭 打开-操作-关闭 <变量名> = open(&l ...

  2. 1前端案例-tag标签+随机位置

    tag标签随机位置+js数组随机+js添加一段html代码段 <!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Transitional//EN ...

  3. 每月IT摘录201911

    技术 1.以 MySQL 的 InnoDB 引擎为例,由于 MySQL 中有两套日志机制,一套是存储层的 redo log,另一套是 server 层的 binlog,每次更新数据都要对两个日志进行更 ...

  4. sumdoc t411 dir.txt

    C:\Users\zhoufeiyue\Documents\sumdoc t411\(9+条消息)redis Jedis存取list对象和map - shenjianxz的博客 - CSDN博客.mh ...

  5. 汪莹:以RELX悦刻为例,复盘中国品牌出海的跨文化挑战

    海外销售额每月2倍增速,3个月拿下东南亚市场第一,出口43个国家,拥有250万用户--你可能不知道,这是一家成立仅一年半.出海仅7个月的中国企业交出的答卷. 这家企业就是中国第一大电子烟品牌RELX悦 ...

  6. Python实现电子词典(图形界面)

    Python实现电子词典(图形界面) 终端电子词典:https://www.cnblogs.com/noonjuan/p/11341375.html 文件一览: .├── client.py├── d ...

  7. Python实现电子词典

    代码一览: dictionary/├── code│   ├── client.py│   ├── func.py│   ├── server.py│   └── settings.py├── dat ...

  8. 解析大型.NET ERP系统 电子邮件系统帐户集成

    为保证ERP系统的信息流准确快速的传递,需要给系统设计一个消息盒子机制.当系统中发生业务操作后,需要提醒下一个环节的操作人员,以保证ERP信息流快速准确传递.比如生产任务单(工作单,加工单,制单)过帐 ...

  9. 【开源】SoDiaoEditor 可能是目前最好用的开源电子病历编辑器(B/S架构)

    此刻我的内心是忐忑的,这个标题给了我很大的压力,虽然很久以前我就在github上搜索一圈了,也没发现有其他更好的开源电子病历编辑器,如各位亲发现有更好的,烦请知会我一声. 该编辑器其实已经憋了很久了, ...

随机推荐

  1. IOS, Android, Java Web Rest : RSA 加密和解密问题

    IOS, Android, Java Web Rest :  RSA 加密和解密问题 一对公钥私钥可以使用 OpenSSL创建, 通常 1024位长度够了. 注意: 1. 公钥私钥是BASE64编码的 ...

  2. IDEA分享项目到GitHub出现Could not read from remote repository

    如果VCS->Import into Version Control->Share Project on GitHub出现如下错误:: 重点在最后一行Could not read from ...

  3. Elasticsearch SQL

    es sql是一个X-pack组件 ,允许对es执行类似sql的查询,可以将Elasticsearch SQL理解为一个编译器,既能理解es,又能理解sql.可以通过利用es,实施大规模实时读取和处理 ...

  4. 模拟curl函数

    只要需要调用微信的网址,就需要模拟curl请求 $tokenUrl="https://api.weixin.qq.com/cgi-bin/token?grant_type=client_cr ...

  5. ansible管理windows (发送文件)

    https://github.com/ansible/ansible/raw/devel/examples/scripts/ConfigureRemotingForAnsible.ps1 环境: 服务 ...

  6. MVC实战之排球计分(三)—— 模型类的设计与实现

    此软件使用的数据库连接方式code first 由EF框架产生数据库. code first需要对模型类设计和实现.模型类是现实实体在计算机中的表示.它贯穿于整个架构, 负担着在各层次及模块间传递数据 ...

  7. Mac OS下安装和配置MongoDB

    安装和配置教程: 参考地址:https://blog.csdn.net/yibowanbo/article/details/80233030 可视化管理工具: 地址:https://blog.csdn ...

  8. 关于export和export default的区别

    ES6的模块化中,export与export default都可以用于导出常量.函数.文件.模块等,我们可以通过在其它文件或模块中import(常量.函数.文件.模块)的方式导入,但在一个文件或模块中 ...

  9. java进行url编码和解码

    public static String getURLEncoderString(String str) { String result = ""; if (null == str ...

  10. hdu1569-方格取数-二分图网络流

    方格取数(2) Time Limit: 10000/5000 MS (Java/Others)    Memory Limit: 65536/32768 K (Java/Others)Total Su ...