Reading With Purpose: A grand experiment
Reading With Purpose: A grand experiment
Reading research papers in mathematical disciplines takes training. A student’s natural tendency is to read a paper from beginning to end in a depth-first manner. Every time they get stuck at a concept, they branch down another path, and then another, to the point where even getting through an abstract for a paper can take days and is exhausting.
Needless to say, this is not the best way to read technical material of any kind, mathematical or otherwise.
I have spent many hours explaining to my students how they should be reading papers, and if you’re reading this and you have students of your own, you’ve probably done the same. While I don’t claim to have the perfect method for reading any given paper, I’ve learnt over the years how to quickly skim a paper, flying over it and scanning the terrain as it were. I’ve learnt when to make a deep dive all the way to ground level, and when to resurface. And above all, I’ve learnt to distinguish the different reasons for reading technical material in the first place, and that each mode requires a different treatment.
I’ve looked all over the web for good material to give to students to learn how to read papers in (theoretical) computer science. I’ve found a few short articles here and there: S. Keshav’s note on reading systems papers, Michael Mitzenmacher’s helpful document, a page by Jason Eisner, and the many blog posts by Terry Tao, to name a few. There are also a number of good short articles on reading mathematics that I’ve drawn some inspiration from.
But none of these capture the essence of what I try to achieve in my reading and what I want my students to be able to do. It’s a kind of Thurstonian ideal of understanding: where the proof falls away and what you’re left with is a deep conceptual appreciation of how the parts of a proof (or a theorem, or a set of definitions) fit together, and what they really mean.
Moreover, if one is to teach the art of reading, it is important not just to describe the goal, but to find a way to get there: with exercises, little practices, and muscle-strengthening activities. This is after all the difference between teaching and showing.
That is my motivation for this collection of notes. It is my attempt to demystify and systematize a set of tools for reading papers. It will not be complete, and it will likely not resemble how you read papers. But hopefully it provides one way of getting to the promised land.
Reading With Purpose: A grand experiment的更多相关文章
- Android内存管理(2)HUNTING YOUR LEAKS: MEMORY MANAGEMENT IN ANDROID PART 2
from: http://www.raizlabs.com/dev/2014/04/hunting-your-leaks-memory-management-in-android-part-2-of- ...
- ACM ICPC 2015 Moscow Subregional Russia, Moscow, Dolgoprudny, October, 18, 2015 D. Delay Time
Problem D. Delay Time Input file: standard input Output file: standard output Time limit: 1 second M ...
- IoT experitment
Abstract: In order to solve the problems of complex experiment management, complicated teaching task ...
- Methods for Identifying Out-of-Trend Results in Ongoing Stability Data
python机器学习-乳腺癌细胞挖掘(博主亲自录制视频) https://study.163.com/course/introduction.htm?courseId=1005269003& ...
- Grand Central Dispatch-thread pool pattern
Grand Central Dispatch (GCD) is a technology developed by Apple Inc. to optimize application support ...
- [Notes] Reading Notes on [Adaptive Robot Control – mxautomation J. Braumann 2015]
Reading sources: 1.Johannes Braumann, Sigrid Brell-Cokcan, Adaptive Robot Control (ARC ) Note: buil ...
- The Power of Reading——英语学习小技巧之七
This method is "The Power of Reading" and it comes from an article by Dr.Stephen Krashen. ...
- CHAPTER 38 Reading ‘the Book of Life’ The Human Genome Project 第38章 阅读生命之书 人体基因组计划
CHAPTER 38 Reading ‘the Book of Life’ The Human Genome Project 第38章 阅读生命之书 人体基因组计划 Humans have about ...
- lightoj 1381 - Scientific Experiment dp
1381 - Scientific Experiment Time Limit: 20 Sec Memory Limit: 256 MB 题目连接 http://www.lightoj.com/vo ...
随机推荐
- “CEPH浅析”系列之六——CEPH与OPENSTACK
在 <"Ceph浅析"系列之二--Ceph概况>中即已提到,关注Ceph的原因之一,就是OpenStack社区对于Ceph的重视.因此,本文将对Ceph在OpenSta ...
- 在Ubuntu 14.04安装Nginx
###介绍 Nginx是世界上最流行的网络服务器中的一种,负责托管网络上一些流量最高的网站.在多数情况下,Nginx比Apache在资源上更加友好,可以作为网络服务器或反向代理服务器. 这篇教程中,我 ...
- Linux下C++静态库、动态库的制作与使用
参考博文:C++静态库与动态库 >> 静态库 1. 静态库的制作 a) 编辑 name.cpp 和name.h文件 b) $g++ -c name.cpp //注意带参数-c,否则直接编译 ...
- java中的hashSet和Treeset的分析
hashset中的元素 treeset中的元素要实现comparable接口
- 初探psutil
系统性能信息模块psutil 1,psutil简介 psutil是一个跨平台能够轻松获取系统的进程和系统利用率,主要应用在系统监控,分析和限制系统资源以及进程管理.它实现了很多系统管理的命令,如ps, ...
- poj1182 带权并查集
食物链 Time Limit: 1000MS Memory Limit: 10000K Total Submissions: 60225 Accepted: 17656 Description ...
- 【深入Java虚拟机】之一:Java内存模型与内存溢出
[深入Java虚拟机]之:Java内存区域与内存溢出 高速缓存模型如下: ----------------------------------------------------分割线-------- ...
- 系统间通信(9)——通信管理与RMI 下篇
接上文<架构设计:系统间通信(8)--通信管理与RMI 上篇>.之前说过,JDK中的RMI框架在JDK1.1.JDK1.2.JDK1.5.JDK1.6+几个版本中做了较大的调整.以下我们讨 ...
- [cf621E]Wet Shark and Blocks
Description 给定$n$个数和$b$个盒子,放一些数到盒子中,使得盒子不为空.每个盒子中的数是一样的,一个数可以被放到多个盒子中. 从每个盒子中取一个数,组成一个$b$位数,如果这个数$mo ...
- 设置CentOS6.5时钟同步
一.测试ntp服务 # rpm -q ntp ntp-4.2.4p8-2.el6.x86_64 // 这表示已安装了,如果没有安装,这是空白. 二./etc/ntp.conf 红色部分是修改的. 配置 ...