JVM Monitoring: JMX or SNMP?

By daniel on Feb 23, 2007

Since JavaTM SE 5.0, the JRE provides a means to manage and monitor the Java Virtual Machine. It comes in two flavors: one is based on the Java Management Extension (JMXTM), the other is a small SNMP agent that builds upon the Management and Monitoring API of the Java SE platform and exposes the same information through SNMP.

A legitimate question that often arises to newcomers to the JMX and SNMP technologies is:

Which technology should I use to monitor my JVM? JMX, or SNMP?

In this blog I will try to provide some guidance on this subject.

Monitoring the JVM through JMX

The JVM JMX agent is composed of a JMX RMI Connector Server which exposes the content of a platform MBeanServer to remote applications. When started, it registers all the platform MXBeans that compose the JVM Monitoring and Management API in the platform MBeanServer, and expose them to remote JMX clients. 
One such client is the popular JConsole graphical tool. 
Follow this link to learn more about managing and monitoring the JVM through JMX
Other links of interest can also be found in What is JMX? and Looking for JMX Overview, Examples, and More....

Monitoring the JVM through SNMP

The JVM SNMP Agent is a small SNMPv2c agent which exposes a single MIB, the JVM-MANAGEMENT-MIB. This agent is not extensible, and can only expose what is defined in that MIB. 
Follow this link to learn how to start and configure the JVM SNMP agent.

In order to manage the JVM through SNMP, you will need to use an SNMP management console, or an SMMP management API. The Java Dynamic Management Kit from Sun provides an SNMP Manager API in Java. There are also a lot of other free or commercial SNMP tools, shells, and command line software, such as e.g. NET-SNMP
A good place to start looking for them is here, or you could also google it use your favorite internet search engine.

Update:Dmitri Maximovitch has written an excellent article explaining how to use MRTG to monitor the JVM, eitherthrough JMX or through the JVM SNMP Agent.

So, Which Management Solution Should I Choose?

Well, in what Java and the JVM is concerned, I would say it's far more interesting to invest in a solution based on JMX rather than on a solution based on SNMP, for the following reasons:

The MIB that makes it possible to manage the JVM through SNMP is closed. The JVM-MANAGEMENT-MIB only exposes the information defined by JSR 163 - and none other. In particular, if you register your own MBeans in the platform MBeanServer, they will not be exposed through that MIB. On the other hand, you will be able to interact with them through a regular JMX connector, and JConsole will display them nicely.

The JVM SNMP Agent is also closed. As I have already explained, it doesn't have a public API. If you wanted to expose your own information through SNMP you would have to:

      1. Find a standard MIB that defines the information you want to expose, or write your own MIB
      2. Use a tool such as the Java Dynamic Management Kit to generate stubs for that MIB
      3. Provide the application logic to implement those stubs
      4. Start a new SNMP agent to expose your MIB.

All of this does require a certain amount of expertise in SNMP.

The power of expression of SNMP/SMI is limited. It is ideally suited to describe and monitor numeric gauges and counters (scalar or tabular), but describing complex data is much more awkward. Some things which could appear trivial in JMX, like for instance, returning a thread stack trace, can reach incredible levels of complexity in SNMP. Describing complex configuration can also rapidly become nightmarish. The possibility of evolution for SNMP interfaces is thus limited: SNMP is a very good protocol - but like any management technologies, it has its strengths, weaknesses, and limitations.

Conclusion

All in all, I would say that choosing to monitor the JVM through SNMP is legitimate when:

  1. The JVMs you want to manage are deployed in a secure network (intranet-like). The JVM SNMP agent is an SNMP v2c agent, and SNMP v2 has basically no security.
  2. You already have at your disposal SNMP management tools or SNMP management consoles
  3. You already have an SNMP background knowledge, so that you will not have to learn everything about SNMP from scratch
  4. You are trying to correlate JVM Monitoring data through non Java management applications which already have an SNMP stack
  5. You are only interested in JVM data - not application data, and do not see any plans for this to change.
  6. What is defined in the JVM-MANAGEMENT-MIB suits your need and is enough for your purposes.

If that is the case, and you answered YES to all questions, then the JVM SNMP Agent was made for you!

Cheers, and stay tuned for more adventurous journeys in the Java, JMX, and SNMP world! 
-- daniel

Category: Sun

Tags: j

JVM Monitoring: JMX or SNMP?的更多相关文章

  1. jvm添加jmx远程监控

    调JVM监控的时候需要远程连接机器,所以服务器需要开放JMX协议,配置如下. 现在我的项目是jboot-jfinal项目,用的是undertow容器,在启动脚本里面加入 JAVA_OPTS=" ...

  2. Monitoring an IBM JVM with VisualVM

    Monitoring an IBM JVM with VisualVM 分类: Java 2013-06-09 16:15 250人阅读 评论(0) 收藏 举报 JDK6 update 7 and o ...

  3. Java Management Extensions (JMX) Flume

    Lesson: Overview of the JMX Technology (The Java™ Tutorials > Java Management Extensions (JMX)) h ...

  4. JMX简单入门

    在一个系统中常常会有一些配置信息,比如服务的IP地址,端口号什么的,那么如何来来处理这些可配置项呢? 程序新手一般是写死在程序里,到要改变时就去改程序,然后再编译发布: 程序熟手则一般把这些信息写在一 ...

  5. JVM Management API

    JVM本身提供了一组管理的API,通过该API,我们可以获取得到JVM内部主要运行信息,包括内存各代的数据.JVM当前所有线程及其栈相关信 息等等.各种JDK自带的剖析工具,包括jps.jstack. ...

  6. 深入理解JVM—性能监控工具

    (转自:http://yhjhappy234.blog.163.com/blog/static/31632832201222691738865/) 我们知道,在JVM编译期和加载器,甚至运行期已经做了 ...

  7. 配置JVM内存 查看内存工具

    一.配置JVM内存 1.配置JVM内存的參数有四个: -XmxJavaHeap最大值.默认值为物理内存的1/4.最佳设值应该视物理内存大小及计算机内其它内存开销而定. -XmsJavaHeap初始值, ...

  8. cacti监控jvm

    jdk环境 java version "1.6.0_37" Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.6.0_37-b06) Java Ho ...

  9. java heap space解决方法和JVM参数设置

    在JVM中如果98%的时间是用于GC(Garbage Collection)且可用的 Heap size 不足2%的时候将抛出异常信息,java.lang.OutOfMemoryError: Java ...

随机推荐

  1. hosts文件配置作用

    hosts文件默认路径: C:\Windows\System32\drivers\etc hosts文件认识 Hosts是一个没有扩展名的系统文件,可以用记事本等工具打开,其作用就是将一些常用的网址域 ...

  2. 对比iOS中的四种数据存储

    来自于大牛的文章给大家分享下 :http://www.infoq.com/cn/articles/data-storage-in-ios/

  3. javascript document对象 第21节

    <html> <head> <title>DOM对象</title> <style type="text/css"> t ...

  4. MinGW-notepad++开发c/c++程序

    下载MinGW 点击下载 安装好后运行 最后点击左上角的 Installation,开始安装 1.编译: g++ -o a.exe a.cpp gcc -o hello.exe hello.c 2.运 ...

  5. 菜鸟笔记之java中方法使用

    N!!!java中无参无返回值方法的使用 1,定义方法 eg: public void show(){ System.out.println("HelloWorld!") } -- ...

  6. CCPC网络赛,HDU_5842 Lweb and String

    Problem Description Lweb has a string $S$. Oneday, he decided to transform this string to a new sequ ...

  7. Windows下ANSI、Unicode、UTF8字符编码转换

    主意:输入字符串必须是以'\0'结尾,如果输入字符串没有以'\0'结尾,请手动设置,否则转换会有错误. unsigned int EncodeUtil::AnsiToUcs2( char* pAnsi ...

  8. linux - Mysql 创建用户和授权

    CREATE USER 'cui'@'%' IDENTIFIED BY 'xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx'; GRANT ALL ON test_db.* TO 'cui'@'%'; REVOK ...

  9. yii2源码学习笔记(十八)

    View继承了component,用于渲染视图文件:yii2\base\View.php <?php /** * @link http://www.yiiframework.com/ * @co ...

  10. CentOS使用sudo提示用户不在sudoers文件中的解决方法

    1切换到root用户[linux@localhost ~]$ su root密码:[root@localhost ~]# 2查看/etc/sudoers文件权限,如果只读权限,修改为可写权限 [roo ...