How should we define the death of a person? Philosophers and physicians have long pondered this question, yet we still don’t have a satisfactory answer. For much of human history, death was synonymous with the cessation of the heartbeat. However, there are patients in hospitals whose hearts are still beating but who appear to be less than fully alive. Are they dead?

Fifty years ago, a Harvard committee tried to bring a modern perspective to this question. The chairman, Henry Beecher, a renowned bioethicist, was motivated by the conundrum of “hopelessly unconscious” patients being kept alive by mechanical ventilation and other newly developed medical technologies. Such patients were “increasing in numbers over the land,” he wrote.

Dr. Beecher’s committee, in a report titled “A Definition of Irreversible Coma,” defined a new state of death — brain death — in which patients were unconscious, unresponsive to pain and unable to breathe on their own, and had no basic reflexes (pupils unreactive to light, no gag reflex and so on). These were conditions suggesting a brain stem that was irreversibly damaged. Such patients, the committee asserted, were in fact dead and could be declared so by a physician. Additional tests, such as a flat brain-wave scan or an angiogram showing no cerebral blood flow, could be used to confirm the diagnosis but were not necessary.

The Harvard committee’s concept of brain death was eventually accepted by states across the country. Today, patients in the United States and many other countries can be declared dead either because their hearts have stopped or because their brains have ceased to function, even if blood is still circulating.

In the years after the Harvard report was published, doctors relied on the concept of brain death to withdraw life support from neurologically devastated patients, curtailing futile care. Just as important, brain-dead patients were declared deceased before their blood had stopped circulating, thus minimizing injury to other vital organs, allowing them to be transplanted. Some physicians believe that facilitating organ transplantation was the Harvard committee’s true aim in redefining death.

“There is great need for the tissues and organs of the hopelessly comatose in order to restore to health those who are still salvageable,” the committee wrote in an early draft of its report — though this sentence did not appear in the final version. In the years just before the report’s publication, doctors had performed the first liver, lung and heart transplants. The number of available organs, then as now, was small, however, and there was a great desire to expand the pool.

In the main, this goal was achieved. After the Harvard committee issued its report, the number of transplanted organs drastically increased, and thousands of patients waiting on organ transplant lists were saved. Today, brain-dead individuals supply most of the transplanted organs in the United States. Because of the opioid epidemic, those numbers have increased. Deaths from opioid overdose now account for about 13 percent of the nation’s organ donors, up from 1 percent two decades ago.

But the concept of brain death was controversial from the start. Many people, including many Native Americans, evangelical Protestants and Orthodox Jews, rejected the concept of brain death for religious or cultural reasons. Even apart from such considerations, a determination of brain death can seem implausible in the face of a healthy body: Some patients who have been declared brain-dead whose life support has not been withdrawn have “survived” with intact organ function for months, even years. These patients often don’t look “dead.” They may have warm skin and a normal complexion and may continue to grow, menstruate, even gestate children. Families still come up to me in the intensive care unit and say: “His heart is beating, Doctor. How can he be dead?”

Because of improvements in technology, organs designated for transplantation today can be nourished and remain viable for longer periods, so it is less critical to remove organs before the heart stops beating. As a result, more organs, especially in Europe, are being removed and transplanted after the more traditional declaration of death: the stoppage of blood circulation. Death in these cases is declared the old-fashioned way, after the heart stops beating, typically after withdrawal of life support. As technology continues to advance, we may even be able to return to the original definition of death, should we want to.

All of which serves as a reminder that our definition of death is man-made. In the spectrum between alive and dead, we set the threshold, and we can do so in response to biological, ethical and even practical considerations. Death is not a binary state or a simple biological fact but a complex social choice.

L304 What Is Death?的更多相关文章

  1. 【清北学堂】 死亡(death)

    M个位置可以打sif,N+1个人等着打sif,已知前N个人的时间,问第N+1个人什么时候才能打sif(不能插队,即必须按顺序来打sif) 输入N,M以及每个人所需要的时间:输出第N+1个人所需的时间 ...

  2. HDU 5860 Death Sequence(死亡序列)

    p.MsoNormal { margin: 0pt; margin-bottom: .0001pt; text-align: justify; font-family: Calibri; font-s ...

  3. Ping of Death

    [Ping of Death] The ping of death attack, or PoD, can cripple a network based on a flaw in the TCP/I ...

  4. 2016暑假多校联合---Death Sequence(递推、前向星)

    原题链接 Problem Description You may heard of the Joseph Problem, the story comes from a Jewish historia ...

  5. 2015年第5本(英文第4本):Death on the Nile尼罗河上的惨案

    书名:Death on the Nile 作者: Agatha Christie 单词数:7.9万(读完后发现网上还有一个版本,总共2.7万单词,孩子都能读懂,看来是简写版) 词汇量:6700 首万词 ...

  6. 模拟实现死亡之Ping(Ping of death)

    需求描述 使用hping构造IP分片,模拟实现死亡之Ping 环境搭建 使用VMWare和Dynamips. 实现思路 构造重装后大于65535字节的IP分片 hping 192.168.1.1 -1 ...

  7. 字符串(AC自动机):HDU 5129 Yong Zheng's Death

    Yong Zheng's Death Time Limit: 20000/10000 MS (Java/Others)    Memory Limit: 512000/512000 K (Java/O ...

  8. HDU 5860 Death Sequence(递推)

    HDU 5860 Death Sequence(递推) 题目链接http://acm.split.hdu.edu.cn/showproblem.php?pid=5860 Description You ...

  9. Educational Codeforces Round 48 (Rated for Div. 2)——A. Death Note ##

    A. Death Note time limit per test 2 seconds memory limit per test 256 megabytes input standard input ...

随机推荐

  1. source code spark

    http://blog.csdn.net/pelick/article/category/1556747 http://www.cnblogs.com/hseagle/

  2. android -------- 解决NDK开发中的 Method 'NewStringUTF' could not be resolved

    创建NDK项目时, .cpp文件中出现错误, Method 'NewStringUTF' could not be resolved 如图: 网上看了很多解决方式 项目右键->属性->c/ ...

  3. Android -------- MVC,MVP 和 MVVM 架构设计模式

    MVC(Model-View-Controller)是最常见的软件架构之一,业界有着广泛应用.它本身很容易理解,但是要讲清楚,它与衍生的 MVP 和 MVVM 架构的区别就不容易了. 一.MVC MV ...

  4. Confluence 6 空间

    什么是一个空间? Confluence 空间是包含有页面和博客页面的容器.你也可以将空间认为是对你工作中可以使用的 2 中类型的目录. 在 Confluence 中有下面 2 种空间类型: 站点空间( ...

  5. adobe

    使用adobe acrobat pro dc可以处理pdf,自动识别,编辑pdf,将pdf导出为word.(收费可破解)

  6. dp 最大正方形

    洛谷P1387 最大正方形 分析:画图模拟,发现以坐标(i,j)为右下顶点的正方形可以根据它左上方的三个点得到,就很轻松写出状态转移方程了. 代码: #include<bits/stdc++.h ...

  7. bzoj2565: 最长双回文串 pam

    题意:找一个串中的最长连续两个回文子串长度 题解:建两个回文树,一个正着,一个反着,每次add之后last的长度就是后缀最长的回文串长度,然后两边加一遍即可 /******************** ...

  8. Spring Boot常用注解

    SpringBoot注解大全   一.注解(annotations)列表 @SpringBootApplication:包含了@ComponentScan.@Configuration和@Enable ...

  9. ireport部署到Linux服务器上遇到的问题解决

    ireport报表在本地Windows环境运行正常,一旦部署到Linux环境上出现了如下问题: 1.打开报表,后台直接报net.sf.jasperreports.engine.util.JRFontN ...

  10. Hadoop介绍-4.Hadoop中NameNode、DataNode、Secondary、NameNode、JobTracker TaskTracker

    Hadoop是一个能够对大量数据进行分布式处理的软体框架,实现了Google的MapReduce编程模型和框架,能够把应用程式分割成许多的 小的工作单元,并把这些单元放到任何集群节点上执行.在MapR ...