The care and maintenance of your adviser

Ever since the advent of graduate school, students have complained about their advisers. It is almost an article of faith. The adviser is never available or is too available; gives too much feedback or not enough; is too critical or isn't providing enough direction; and so on. Exchanging horror stories with other students is a great way to bond. But advising goes both ways — and if, after careful reflection on their own studies and progress, students determine that they are not getting the guidance they require, they must address the deficiencies.

It is not surprising that advisers figure large in graduate students' conversations. In 2009, the US Council of Graduate Schools in Washington DC reported survey results showing that 65% of the 1,856 doctoral students who responded identified mentoring or advising as a main factor in PhD completion. Our own research at Flinders University in Adelaide, Australia, and our experience at graduate-student workshops across the world suggest that the adviser–student relationship has a big impact on completion time. It certainly influences whether students are still smiling at the end of their degrees!

Students often assume that once they call someone an adviser, he or she automatically acquires all the skills of advising. After all, if your adviser is the world leader in stem-cell technology, he or she must excel at the seemingly simple task of advising — not to mention possess highly developed interpersonal skills and a keen interest in graduate-student development. Sadly, that is not the case.

IMAGES.COM/CORBIS

Sometimes, advising is a weakness of an otherwise very accomplished scientist. This is not surprising. Mentoring tends to be a private business, and often the only model available is an adviser's own experience of having been advised. If it was good, they decide to copy that style and methodology; if it was bad, they do the opposite. There is no guarantee that either approach will provide the student with the guidance he or she needs.

A proactive approach is necessary. If your adviser isn't looking after you in the way you need, then you need to look after them. At some point in the PhD journey, most graduate students come to an important realization: “This is my thesis. My name is written on the front of it. I need to become the driver.” The sooner the candidate does this, the better. If you're not getting feedback, clear direction or the necessary resources, then you must do something about it. What does this mean in practice? Let us take some examples.

Meetings

A comment we often hear at our workshops is, “My adviser is lovely but he/she is just so busy that we never get to talk about my thesis”. And our response is, “Yes, your adviser is busy. All advisers are busy and will continue to be busy. Regardless, you need to organize meetings where you can get real face time and talk about your thesis.” We're not recommending a quick chat in the coffee room or a brief word in the lab. Nor do we mean a lab meeting.

We mean regularly scheduled meetings focusing on your thesis. You will probably have to schedule them and follow up to make sure that they happen. And when a meeting is cancelled, you will have to reschedule it and persist until it happens.

In our experience, just scheduling the meeting isn't enough. You can't assume that your adviser hosts productive meetings or can intuit what you need to know. You need a specific, uncomplicated agenda that could include such action items as what you've done in the past two weeks; feedback on written work; what you'll do in the next two weeks; the next meeting.

This all sounds very straightforward. But if more students followed these steps, many adviser–student issues could be resolved.

Feedback

Again, in an ideal world, your adviser would be skilled at providing supportive comments, delicate in pointing out areas for improvement and deft at intuitively knowing the level of feedback you seek. But this is a fantasy. One student described her feedback experience as similar to being a victim in a drive-by shooting — she handed over her work, it was riddled with bullets and she was left with a bloodied mess as the shooter drove off.

To be fair, e-mailing a chapter to an adviser and saying “Give me feedback” is like walking into a restaurant and saying “Give me food.” You need to be a bit more specific. When handing over your work, identify the type of feedback you are looking for. You might say, “This is an early draft, so I just want feedback on the overall direction,” or “Please focus on the discussion on page six.” If the feedback you get isn't helpful, ask for more detail. Maintaining your adviser means asking for what you need rather than hoping that he or she will know what to provide.

Managing up

One of the secrets of looking after your adviser is working out what they want — and what most advisers want is a student who comes to them with suggestions and solutions as well as problems, gets things done and makes the job of advising easier. In business this is called 'managing up'. When we work with graduate students we call it the 'care and maintenance' of your adviser.

So although it is natural to complain about your adviser — and can even be cathartic — it is not enough. If your adviser is not giving you what you need, you need to go out and get it.


Reference: 

  https://www.nature.com/naturejobs/science/articles/10.1038/nj7331-570a

(转) The care and maintenance of your adviser的更多相关文章

  1. 第24/24周 数据库维护(Database Maintenance)

    哇哦,光阴似箭!欢迎回到性能调优培训的最后一期.今天我会详细讲下SQL Server里的数据库维护,尤其是索引维护操作,还有如何进行数据库维护. 索引维护 作为一个DBA,数据库维护是你工作中非常重要 ...

  2. 玩转PowerShell第三节——【SCOM Maintenance Mode】-技术&分享

    概述 Microsoft System Center Operations Manager 2007 sp1(SCOM)是微软推出的专业系统监控软件,可以监控部署在网络中的服务器.应用系统和客户端,提 ...

  3. cloud maintenance of OpenNebula

    OpenNebula 4.4.1 maintenance release,官方建议当前的生产环境使用3.x or 4.x的其它版本; php调用curl工具伪造ip Upgrading from Op ...

  4. gdb在运行maintenance info program-spaces命令时coredump

    coredump时的信息: (gdb) maintenance info program-spaces *** Error in `gdb': free(): invalid pointer: 0x0 ...

  5. Setup SQL Server 2008 Maintenance Plan Email Notifications

    一条龙作完,如何设置EXCHANGE的操作员邮件通知.. ~~~~ http://808techblog.com/2009/07/setup-sql-server-2008-maintena.html ...

  6. The server is temporarily unable to service your request due to maintenance downtime or capacity problems. Please try again later.

    The server is temporarily unable to service your request due to maintenance downtime or capacity pro ...

  7. 产品 线上 保持 和 支持 服务 (Support and maintenance solutions)

    Maintenance and support are the key factors for the smooth functioning of ERP solutions. ERP mainten ...

  8. 一个"Median Maintenance"问题

    题目要求: Download the text file here. The goal of this problem is to implement the "Median Mainten ...

  9. Maste Note for OCR / Vote disk Maintenance Operations (ADD/REMOVE/REPLACE/MOVE)

    Doc ID 428681.1 Applies to: Oracle Database - Enterprise Edition - Version 10.2.0.1 to 11.2.0.1.0 [R ...

随机推荐

  1. linux本地机上传文件到服务器

    最近工作全部切换到了linux环境下,就是吃喝拉撒全在linux下,微信,web端,qq,web端,-------,各种socket编程,网络通讯- 本地linux机从阿里云下载文件

  2. JavaScript--元素对象方法setAttribute() 和appendChild()

    appendChild() 方法可向节点的子节点列表的末尾添加新的子节点 setAttribute() 方法创建或改变某个新属性.如果指定属性已经存在,则只设置该值 <!DOCTYPE html ...

  3. 【CDH学习之二】ClouderaManager安装

    环境 虚拟机:VMware 10 Linux版本:CentOS-6.5-x86_64 客户端:Xshell4 FTP:Xftp4 jdk8 zookeeper-3.4.11 搭建方案:   serve ...

  4. 批量下载网站图片的Python实用小工具(下)

    引子 在 批量下载网站图片的Python实用小工具 一文中,讲解了开发一个Python小工具来实现网站图片的并发批量拉取.不过那个工具仅限于特定网站的特定规则,本文将基于其代码实现,开发一个更加通用的 ...

  5. Jmeter下进行ip伪造

    转至https://blog.csdn.net/xingchao416/article/details/53506051 1.首先获取一些闲置的ip地址,且必须为固定地址,不能是自动获取的地址,方法: ...

  6. USMART 组件移植到STM32

    USMART是由ALIENTEK开发的一个串口调试助手组件,通过它可以通过串口调试助手,调用程序里面的任何函数并执行,单个函数最多支持10个输入参数,并支持函数返回值显示. USMART支持的参数类型 ...

  7. 通过junit/TestNG+java 实现自动化测试

    第一步 安装JDK JDk1.7. 下载地址:http://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk7-downloads-188026 ...

  8. python-数据分析与展示(Numpy、matplotlib、pandas)---2

    笔记内容整理自mooc上北京理工大学嵩天老师python系列课程数据分析与展示,本人小白一枚,如有不对,多加指正 1.python自带的图像库PIL 1.1常用API  Image.open()    ...

  9. MySQL SELECT练习题*28

    -- (1)用子查询查询员工“张小娟”所做的订单信息. SELECT * FROM order_master WHERE saler_no = ( SELECT employee_no FROM em ...

  10. python通过sftp远程传输文件

    python提供了一个第三方模块paramiko,通过这个模块可以实现两台机器之间的网络连接,sftp是paramiko的一个方法,使用sftp可以在两台机器之间互相传输 拷贝文件.然而paramik ...