The care and maintenance of your adviser

Ever since the advent of graduate school, students have complained about their advisers. It is almost an article of faith. The adviser is never available or is too available; gives too much feedback or not enough; is too critical or isn't providing enough direction; and so on. Exchanging horror stories with other students is a great way to bond. But advising goes both ways — and if, after careful reflection on their own studies and progress, students determine that they are not getting the guidance they require, they must address the deficiencies.

It is not surprising that advisers figure large in graduate students' conversations. In 2009, the US Council of Graduate Schools in Washington DC reported survey results showing that 65% of the 1,856 doctoral students who responded identified mentoring or advising as a main factor in PhD completion. Our own research at Flinders University in Adelaide, Australia, and our experience at graduate-student workshops across the world suggest that the adviser–student relationship has a big impact on completion time. It certainly influences whether students are still smiling at the end of their degrees!

Students often assume that once they call someone an adviser, he or she automatically acquires all the skills of advising. After all, if your adviser is the world leader in stem-cell technology, he or she must excel at the seemingly simple task of advising — not to mention possess highly developed interpersonal skills and a keen interest in graduate-student development. Sadly, that is not the case.

IMAGES.COM/CORBIS

Sometimes, advising is a weakness of an otherwise very accomplished scientist. This is not surprising. Mentoring tends to be a private business, and often the only model available is an adviser's own experience of having been advised. If it was good, they decide to copy that style and methodology; if it was bad, they do the opposite. There is no guarantee that either approach will provide the student with the guidance he or she needs.

A proactive approach is necessary. If your adviser isn't looking after you in the way you need, then you need to look after them. At some point in the PhD journey, most graduate students come to an important realization: “This is my thesis. My name is written on the front of it. I need to become the driver.” The sooner the candidate does this, the better. If you're not getting feedback, clear direction or the necessary resources, then you must do something about it. What does this mean in practice? Let us take some examples.

Meetings

A comment we often hear at our workshops is, “My adviser is lovely but he/she is just so busy that we never get to talk about my thesis”. And our response is, “Yes, your adviser is busy. All advisers are busy and will continue to be busy. Regardless, you need to organize meetings where you can get real face time and talk about your thesis.” We're not recommending a quick chat in the coffee room or a brief word in the lab. Nor do we mean a lab meeting.

We mean regularly scheduled meetings focusing on your thesis. You will probably have to schedule them and follow up to make sure that they happen. And when a meeting is cancelled, you will have to reschedule it and persist until it happens.

In our experience, just scheduling the meeting isn't enough. You can't assume that your adviser hosts productive meetings or can intuit what you need to know. You need a specific, uncomplicated agenda that could include such action items as what you've done in the past two weeks; feedback on written work; what you'll do in the next two weeks; the next meeting.

This all sounds very straightforward. But if more students followed these steps, many adviser–student issues could be resolved.

Feedback

Again, in an ideal world, your adviser would be skilled at providing supportive comments, delicate in pointing out areas for improvement and deft at intuitively knowing the level of feedback you seek. But this is a fantasy. One student described her feedback experience as similar to being a victim in a drive-by shooting — she handed over her work, it was riddled with bullets and she was left with a bloodied mess as the shooter drove off.

To be fair, e-mailing a chapter to an adviser and saying “Give me feedback” is like walking into a restaurant and saying “Give me food.” You need to be a bit more specific. When handing over your work, identify the type of feedback you are looking for. You might say, “This is an early draft, so I just want feedback on the overall direction,” or “Please focus on the discussion on page six.” If the feedback you get isn't helpful, ask for more detail. Maintaining your adviser means asking for what you need rather than hoping that he or she will know what to provide.

Managing up

One of the secrets of looking after your adviser is working out what they want — and what most advisers want is a student who comes to them with suggestions and solutions as well as problems, gets things done and makes the job of advising easier. In business this is called 'managing up'. When we work with graduate students we call it the 'care and maintenance' of your adviser.

So although it is natural to complain about your adviser — and can even be cathartic — it is not enough. If your adviser is not giving you what you need, you need to go out and get it.


Reference: 

  https://www.nature.com/naturejobs/science/articles/10.1038/nj7331-570a

(转) The care and maintenance of your adviser的更多相关文章

  1. 第24/24周 数据库维护(Database Maintenance)

    哇哦,光阴似箭!欢迎回到性能调优培训的最后一期.今天我会详细讲下SQL Server里的数据库维护,尤其是索引维护操作,还有如何进行数据库维护. 索引维护 作为一个DBA,数据库维护是你工作中非常重要 ...

  2. 玩转PowerShell第三节——【SCOM Maintenance Mode】-技术&分享

    概述 Microsoft System Center Operations Manager 2007 sp1(SCOM)是微软推出的专业系统监控软件,可以监控部署在网络中的服务器.应用系统和客户端,提 ...

  3. cloud maintenance of OpenNebula

    OpenNebula 4.4.1 maintenance release,官方建议当前的生产环境使用3.x or 4.x的其它版本; php调用curl工具伪造ip Upgrading from Op ...

  4. gdb在运行maintenance info program-spaces命令时coredump

    coredump时的信息: (gdb) maintenance info program-spaces *** Error in `gdb': free(): invalid pointer: 0x0 ...

  5. Setup SQL Server 2008 Maintenance Plan Email Notifications

    一条龙作完,如何设置EXCHANGE的操作员邮件通知.. ~~~~ http://808techblog.com/2009/07/setup-sql-server-2008-maintena.html ...

  6. The server is temporarily unable to service your request due to maintenance downtime or capacity problems. Please try again later.

    The server is temporarily unable to service your request due to maintenance downtime or capacity pro ...

  7. 产品 线上 保持 和 支持 服务 (Support and maintenance solutions)

    Maintenance and support are the key factors for the smooth functioning of ERP solutions. ERP mainten ...

  8. 一个"Median Maintenance"问题

    题目要求: Download the text file here. The goal of this problem is to implement the "Median Mainten ...

  9. Maste Note for OCR / Vote disk Maintenance Operations (ADD/REMOVE/REPLACE/MOVE)

    Doc ID 428681.1 Applies to: Oracle Database - Enterprise Edition - Version 10.2.0.1 to 11.2.0.1.0 [R ...

随机推荐

  1. maven 常用 Archetypes

    maven 常用 Archetypes Archetypes简介 什么是原型? 简而言之,Archetype是一个Maven项目模板工具包.原型被定义为原始模式或模型,从中创建所有其他相同类型的东西. ...

  2. mysql分区/分片

    一.分区概念 mysql 5.1 以后支持分区, 有点类似MongoDB中的分片概念. 就是按照一定的规则, 将一个数据库表分解成很多细小的表, 这些细小的表可以是物理的分区, 就是在不同的位置. 但 ...

  3. laravel 服务容器实例——深入理解IoC模式

    刚刚接触laravel,对于laravel的服务容器不是很理解.看了<Laravel框架关键技术解析>和网上的一些资料后对于服务容器有了一些自己的理解,在这里分享给大家 1.依赖 IoC模 ...

  4. 【转】Kylin系列-使用Saiku+Kylin构建多维分析OLAP平台

    关于Kylin的介绍和使用请参考之前的文章 <分布式大数据多维分析(OLAP)引擎Apache Kylin安装配置及使用示例> Kylin对外提供的是SQL查询接口,基于Kylin构建OL ...

  5. Linux基础命令---杀死进程pkill

    pkill pkill可以给指定的进程发送信息,它可以结束某个执行的进程或者目录登录的用户. 此命令的适用范围:RedHat.RHEL.Ubuntu.CentOS.SUSE.openSUSE.Fedo ...

  6. Qt读取TXT文件时,GBK与UTF-8编码判断

    读取txt文件时,很多时候无法获取文件的编码格式.如果直接进行使用,则有可能出现乱码.需要在使用前将其转为Unicode(Qt的默认编码格式). 虽然实际的编码格式种类非常多,但平常主要使用的有GBK ...

  7. Codeforce 287A - IQ Test (模拟)

    In the city of Ultima Thule job applicants are often offered an IQ test. The test is as follows: the ...

  8. SQL非域环境下带自动故障转移数据库镜像的实现方法(包括镜像服务器)

    使用数据库镜像来提高数据库的高可用性,在镜像服务器创建镜像数据库的快照以卸载报表查询对生产数据库的负载.TechNet有讲座对此技术进行介绍,但看到大家在讲座的讨论区中遇到了很多问题,下面我把在非域环 ...

  9. Django框架----命名空间模式

    命名空间模式 即使不同的APP使用相同的URL名称,URL的命名空间模式也可以让你唯一反转命名的URL. 举个例子: project中的urls.py from django.conf.urls im ...

  10. 在centos上搭建Git服务器

    第一步:先安装一些相关依赖库和编译工具 yum install curl-devel expat-devel gettext-devel openssl-devel zlib-devel yum in ...